News

Last Update :4/5/2021

Chesdin Landing homeowners sue over assessments to fund golf course

Chesdin Landing's entrance off Ivey Mill Road in southern Chesterfield County (Jonathan Spiers photos)

A dispute over assessments charged to homeowners in Chesdin Landing to help fund the neighborhood’s privately owned golf course is playing out in court, with an initial round going to its developer and board of directors.

Dismissal is pending in a lawsuit filed in Chesterfield Circuit Court that alleged the board of the community’s property owners association hoodwinked residents into amending the POA’s covenants, causing them to potentially pay out upwards of $300,000 collectively for the benefit of Lake Chesdin Golf Club.

The suit was filed in December by Bernadette (“Bernie”) Stewart-Johns, a 14-year resident, on behalf of all Chesdin Landing homeowners, who took part in a vote last summer that approved a roughly $1,000-per-home fee.

Stewart-Johns alleged that board members, including Chesdin Landing developer W. Scott Camp, misrepresented the vote by not specifying that the covenants would be amended to put the golf course under the POA’s services – opening the door, the suit argued, to future assessments without homeowner approval.

The suit alleged that the golf course, which anchors the 3,000-acre community in southern Chesterfield County, was profitable last year, despite claims by board members that it was in “dire financial need” and that the assessment was necessary to keep the course going and prevent residential property values from falling.

It also argued that the vote violated the state Property Owners’ Association Act, because the money from the assessment is benefiting a privately owned business and not common areas or other responsibilities laid out in the POA’s covenants.

While those covenants have since been changed and recorded, Matthew Weinberg, Stewart-Johns’ attorney, said the board’s actions still violated the POA Act.

“That’s really the bulk of the issue,” Weinberg said, “whether or not you can get a (POA) to provide funds to a privately owned golf course or to a privately owned business, when the allocation of those funds was not included in your original articles of incorporation and bylaws.”

At a March 16 hearing, Chesdin Landing’s attorneys argued that a subsequent POA vote held earlier that month made two of the lawsuit’s claims moot, leading Judge T.J. Hauler to side with them in their request to dismiss the case.

An order granting the request remained pending as of last week. Once entered with the court, Stewart-Johns would have three weeks to file an amended complaint without the two claims at issue: intentional misrepresentation, and breach of fiduciary duty.

Weinberg, with Virginia Beach firm Inman & Strickler, said after the hearing that he and Stewart-Johns were determining whether to pursue an amended complaint or appeal the ruling to the Virginia Supreme Court.

The suit sought an injunction on all assessments for the golf club, removal of all members of the POA board, and damages totaling $350,000, representing the amount that the assessments would collect over time.

Weinberg is working the case with Michael Inman of Inman & Strickler. Camp and the board are represented by Charles Sims and Rachael Loughlin with Richmond firm O’Hagan Meyer.

The clubhouse for Lake Chesdin GolfClub, which anchors the 3,000 acre residential community

‘This will open a Pandora’s box’

Stewart-Johns, who formed a nonprofit group called Chesdin Landing Advocacy to raise awareness and legal fees, said she has support from more than 100 neighbors in the roughly 350-home community. The group has a GoFundMe page that, as of Wednesday, had raised $8,400 of a $10,000 goal from 40 donors.

“I’m not standing on that complaint alone,” Stewart-Johns said last week. “I’m the one with my name on the paperwork, but I’m not doing this by myself.

“If a court does not look at it the way we see it, this will open a Pandora’s box to any community member who lives in a property association anywhere in Virginia that has a developer and a private business inside the subdivision,” she said.

Camp, who’s been developing Chesdin Landing since the mid-1990s and is one of four board members named as defendants in the suit, said after the hearing that he considered the lawsuit resolved, though he added that the legal fight is not over.

“We’re going to countersue these residents to recoup some of the monies, because it was a frivolous lawsuit to start with and the judge agreed,” Camp said.

“Everybody tells me, ‘Let it go, we won it,’ and I’m thankful for that, but I don’t want somebody else trying to challenge us on anything we do as it pertains to our property owners association or this golf course,” Camp said. “We’re doing what’s in the best interest of the community and the golf course as it pertains to the board of directors.”

Camp said the assessment, which homeowners are paying in installments over three years, has already had a positive effect on the 18-hole golf course, which opened in 1998 and briefly joined forces with Meadowbrook Country Club before that arrangement dissolved several years ago.

“The golf course now is thriving,” he said. “(The assessment) has given us the opportunity to replace a lot of the equipment that we needed and repairs to the golf course, to bring it up to an 18-hole championship golf course, one of the best in Richmond, Virginia.”

Stewart-Johns said the advocacy group wants the golf course to thrive, just not on the backs of property owners who didn’t buy their homes thinking they’d have to subsidize it.

“Everybody is fearful that we’re going to lose our property values if we don’t support the golf course. But we do support the golf course,” she said of the group. “We don’t support changing our covenants to do it. We want to find another way for them to get the money that they need.”

Construction has started in the new 55-and-up "The Masters at Chesdin Landing" section

New home section starts; Summer Lake suit settled

As that case was playing out, another lawsuit involving Camp came to a close, this one relating to his Summer Lake development, also in Chesterfield.

A $20 million suit filed in 2019 by Camp’s former business partner on Summer Lake was withdrawn in late January after reaching a resolution through confidential arbitration. The arbitration was handled by The McCammon Group, a regional firm with an office in Henrico.

The 300-acre development in Chesterfield’s Moseley area is playing host to this year’s Richmond Homearama, marking the second time that Summer Lake has hosted the annual home showcase put on by the Home Building Association of Richmond.

Meanwhile, back at Chesdin Landing, Camp is moving forward with a new section of home lots on the golf course. Called The Masters at Chesdin Landing, the 80-home section will add to the roughly 350 homes already built at Chesdin Landing, which is ultimately planned for 700 homes.

The “active adult” homes in The Masters target homebuyers 55 and up and will range from 2,300 to 2,900 square feet, with prices ranging from $495,000 to $600,000, Camp said. Clay Street Builders, out of Powhatan, is building the homes, which are being sold by Long & Foster’s Base Camp Group.

Story Credited to Jonathan Spiers in Richmond BiZSENSE 4/5/2021



[ More News ]


Join NGCOA Mid-Atlantic - Great Membership Benefits!

Register for the 2021 NGCOA Mid-Atlantic Annual Meeting at Trump National Washington DC, October 21

Golf Course Acquisition Opportunity - Maryland - For Sale By Auction

Employee Retention Tax Credit May Save You Thousands $

Partner News: Hilda A. Allen real estate, inc. - 2 Florida Golf Courses for Sale

Glenwood Golf Course redevelopment gets planning commission approval

Google's New "Local" Ads Provide Big Advantages to Golf Courses

The Appraisal Journal - Valuation of Private Clubs for Tax Assessments

Clubhouse of the Year: Call for Entries for 2021 Competition - deadline July 23

2021 A Club Leader's Perspective: Emerging Trends & Challenges Report

Morning Read and Sports Illustrated Announce Editorial Partnership

Multi-Course Owners Retreat in NOV 9-10 in Monterey, CA

Partner News: Richard Mandell Architecture "Form and Function" Summer 2021

Women's Golf Day 2021 Sets New Global Records

Is it Time to Review Your Golf Property Tax Assessment?

Golf Industry Unites Around Momentum, DEI Collaboration during 2021 National Golf Day

Spring Issue Mid-Atlantic Golf Business Joint with North Carolina GCOA

Lake Presidential Golf Club in Upper Marlboro, MD Recently Sold

National Golf Day 2021 Set to Bring Golf Industry Together for Virtual Celebration May 12

Advocacy Alerts Digest for Friday, April 9, 2021

VSGA Seeks Assistant Director of Finance & Administration - click here

Chesdin Landing homeowners sue over assessments to fund golf course

Golf Property Values, The Right # of Members and Tom Bennison

NGCOA CEO Jay Karen Joins U.S. Travel Association Board of Directors

2020 Excellence in Club Management Award Winners Announced

PGA Tour Superstore Teams up to Become Official Retailer for Women's Golf Day

Register Today for the Early Bird Rate: 2021 National Club Conference

Three VA golf courses sell to maximize the 2020 golf course sales year at Smith Mountain Lake

Chambers Acquires Golf Business Advisors

Get Your 2021 Virginia Golf Trip Price

Governor Ralph Northam Announces New COVID-19 Restrictions

Nov Golf Playable Hours/October Utilization are off the chart!

Save the dates for Golf Business Conference 2021

Fairfax County Park Authority Names New Director of Golf Operations

Oct Weather unusually flat, September Utilization continues to impress!

Oct OtR Full Issue - Bets on '21 Anyone?

Chip Shots - Adaptability, Necessity & Joe Krenn shares his thoughts

Public Golf Leader Award - Golden Horseshoe Golf Club

Mid-Atlantic Golf Leader Award - Henry Wallmeyer

Sustainability Leader - US Naval Academy Golf Club

Private Golf Leader Award - Elizabeth Manor Golf & Country Club

Important Announcement regarding the 2021 PGA Merchandise Show

We Can Help Your Club

NGCOA MA Annual Golf Outing is Oct. 22 at Golden Horseshoe GC, Williamsburg - click for info and to register

​Is it time to review your property tax assessment?

VSGA granted 501 (c) (3) status by IRS

NGCOA SPONSORS INAUGURAL AFRICAN AMERICAN GOLF EXPO & FORUM IN FEBRUARY 2021

NATIONAL LINKS TRUST SIGNS LEASE WITH NATIONAL PARK SERVICE

Aquisition Opportunity | Lake Presidential Golf Club

Owner says SELL!!

Partner News: Hilda W. Allen real estate, inc. Property Preview - Skyland Lakes Golf Club

How Can We Help Your Club?

​Is it Time to review your property tax assessment?

A location change for Golf Business RevCon 2020

Golf Property Analysts - your "go to" for help with effects of the pandemic

Fairfax Co. Seeks Director of Golf Operations

Special Report from NGCOA - The Golf Industry's Participation in PPP

Exclusive Offer to NGCOA Members - Upgrade Insurance Services

Your NGCOA membership = free entry to RevCon20

Save-the-Dates - Oct. 22 - NGCOA MA Annual Golf Outing presented by Brightview, Williamsburg, VA - details coming soon

NGF Report - Equipment bouncing back, golf travel still grounded

Smith Mountain Lake Property Preview July 15th - price reduction

Farmington’s Johnson Recognized Nationally

Prime Fall Tee Times Going Fast in VA, Get a Jump on Trip Planning

Up to Par Management Renews its Support of NGCOA MA

Is it Time for Your Club's Tax Assessment?

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

VISA & MasterCard Class Action Suit Update

NGCOA Announces Award Winners for 2020

Breaking News: Belmont Golf Course would get $4M transformation in deal with First Tee

2019 NGCOA MA Fall Newsletter

Richmond Tour Event at CCV is #1

NBC Sports buys Chicago golf-booking company

VGM Club Changes Name to ClubProcure

End of Year Review: Business Intelligence

CIB: Where Clubs Meet Member Needs

The Latest News For You

Golf Course Opportunities

House Passes Corporate Transparency Act of 2019

NGCOA Offers Members Hospitality Training and Resources Through New Partnership

End of Year Review: Pro Shop KPIs

Oct Perspective: Debunking Supply Begets Demand

Golf retailer Club Champion swings into Short Pump

To Barter Or Not To Barter: THAT is the opportunity cost question

Know how you stack up against your competitor's performance with Benchmark

Skyland Lakes Golf Club!

Topgolf tees off in Richmond

What you need to know about late fall golf trips

Upgrade Your Employee Benefits Solution with NGCOA Insurance Benefits

Golf Course Opportunities

Heatherwood Hills Property Preview

Access Resources from NGCOA MA Annual Meeting - presentation decks & more - click here

Godzilla vs. Gorilla for the Golf Course Win!

WOTUS Repealed

Episode 30 of the NGCOA Golf Business Podcast

Drive Shack to be first-to-market in Richmond ahead of Topgolf

GPA 2019 Market Report

Elizabeth Manor Golf and Country Club in Portsmouth to be sold

Exempting the "Golf Teaching Professionals"

Henrico issues RFP to lease Belmont Golf Course to outside operator

Head to the Mountains and golf Virginia this fall

Recession?, Member Appreciation, Refurbish?

CIB: Why Wyles Won the Excellence in Club Management Award

New Course Owners And Homeowners Save Skybrook Golf Community

Aug Perspective, Are Merchant Fees Barter 2.0?

Golf Business Podcast: Save money, make money

Giles' Kinloch gem receives touch-up

Bulle Rock Golf Club: Call for Offers

The Jay Karen Story

Mid-Atlantic Golf Business Newsletter now available - click here

July OtR Abstract: Profiling H1 '19 Supply Changes

Increase Membership Sales: E-commerce Tool

Obedience training for the "dog days" of summer

How Non-Golfers view Golf, Market Intelligence & Design Features that Matter

Need an Exit Strategy for your Club or Golf Course?

Ropes Course Rising on Outskirts of Independence Golf Club in Richmond!

July Perspective, Drive Shack Q1 results vs. TopGolf

The Highland Course at Primland Ranked Among Top Greatest Public Courses by Golf Digest

Ratcliffe Golf Services Thriving with Chronogolf by Lightspeed and ChronoPitch

LaMott Smith Announced as Director of Business Development for One Source Partnership

Branding, Club Tax Assessments & Course Rankings

NGCOA Partners with First American Payment Systems

PGA of America Becomes NGCOA Executive Partner

Poplar Grove Golf Club Completes Phase 1 of Planned Renovations

Kitchen Cocktail Parties at CCV

KemperSports-Managed Properties Earn Top Honors

Golf & Club Tax Assessments - Did you know?

2019 Golf Participation Report + The Skinny on Municipal Golf

Hurricane Season is Upon Us...Is Your Business Prepared?

Golf & Club Tax Assessments

Chronogolf acquired by leading Cloud POS software company

National Golf Day, Drones Save $, RE Tax Confusion & More

Reston National Golf Course sold to pair of Baltimore developers

Industry Around the Globe Unites in Support of Women's Golf Day

Golf Industry Comes Together for 12th Annual National Golf Day

Pillsbury and Harbin Join NGCOA Board; Barton Hired as Director of Programs

National Golf Foundation Releases 2019 Golf Industry Report

Golf Complex Recognized as Billy Casper Golf's 'Best of the Best'

Golf Digest Names Yamaha the Best Gas-powered Club Car for 3rd Consecutive Year

Royal New Kent Golf Club Reopens after 18-month Hiatus

CIB: How Today's Clubs Keep Up with the Times

Clubhouses, Changes in Tax Assessments and Golf Property Acquisition Opportunities

Meet the Veteran Golfers Association

DOL Issues New Proposed Overtime Rule

Excellence in Club Management: Patrick King, CCM, CCE, ECM

Selling Your Golf Course? Think GPA.

Visa/Mastercard $6B Class Action Lawsuit Update

NCA Webinar: Managing Your Club's Real Estate Tax Assessment

Mid-Atlantic Golf Business Winter Newsletter

Chronogolf Publishes Collection of Customer Stories

Congress Approves Increase in H-2B Visas

Billy Casper Golf Selected to Manage Brickshire Golf Club

Chronogolf Publishes Free Social Media Planning Template

Congress Approves Increase in H-2B Visas

Another Local Golf Course Sold, This Time for $1.2M

Golf Course Owners You May Be Eligible to Share in $6B Class Action Settlement

Golf Simulator Venue Opens Across from Scott's Addition

NEW! NGCOA Member Benefit: Insurance

The MAJOR of Golf Business

Area Golf Course Sold for $800,000

Troon Named "Management Company of the Year" for 5th Consecutive Year

BOYNE GOLF - Heather Named NGCOA National Course of the Year

Billy Casper Golf Celebrates 4th Decade Unmatched in Industry Innovation

Topgolf's Richmond Property Sold to Investment Firm

Golf Life Navigators Partners with Jeff Fleishman to Drive VA Expansion

Virginia Golf Has It All

Dec OtR Abstract: '18 Forgettable, but not as bad as it looks

Is a new irrigation system in your future?

Next Generation Golf Business Leaders + Useful Insights from Industry Veterans

Pepsi is ready to write you a rebate check!

The 2019 National Club Conferences is a Once-in-a-Lifetime Opportunity

Vestavia CC Named One of the Best New Courses of 2018

How Much Does Golf Cost?, Municipal Golf, Is Your Management Company Effective?

EZLinks Golf's EZ24 PRO Reservation Center Surpasses 75 Million Rounds Booked

2019 MAPGA Section Award Recipients

CIB: 9 Industry Stats Impacting Clubs Into Next Year

Kingsmill LPGA event lands title sponsor

Nov Perspective: Virtual golf at facilities producing reality revenue

Magazine honors Billy Casper Golf's Hill

Williamsburg National Voted Best Golf Course in Williamsburg

CIB: Overcoming The Board Diversity Problem

UR readies new golf facility at Independence

Is your Website ADA Compliant?

Poplar Grove Golf Club Selects Buffalo.Agency to Manage Public Relations

Take the Horror out of Managing Your Club's Real Estate Tax Assessment

Find Significant Savings From 800+ Suppliers

A Jam Packed Issue of CHIP SHOTS!

2018 NGCOA Mid-Atlantic Innovation Awards

Annual Meeting Presentation Library - click to download: Lester George on Market Trends, Sean Taylor Case Study, Brad Steele Government Relations

NGCOA CEO Puts Personal Test to Member Program

New Golf Media Report, PLUS the ROI on Course Renovations

PGA, Dominion Strike Deal to Extend Richmond Tourney through 2029

Cushman Welcomes New 4x4 Series to Hauler Family

Club Prophet Systems Meets Golf Businesses Coast to Coast

Global Consensus for Golf in the Race to Tackle Physical Inactivity

Mid-Atlantic Golf Business Fall Newsletter - Click Here

Selling the Game through Facebook, Instagram and Twitter

CIB: Is a Blue Wave Coming for Clubs?

 

 

Chronogolf Podcast: The Ryder Cup with Paul Armitage

New PGA Tour Record for Charitable Donations

Golf Property & Club Tax Assessments

WOTUS Update - Still a Risk to Golf

Independent Contractors - Are you in Compliance?

Aug Weather Impact: 3rd consecutive sideways month

General Motors Becomes NGCOA's Newest Corporate Partner

Vestavia Country Club reopens course to deserved acclaim

Playing Conditions, Who's the Buyer, Scotland & The Practice Tee

U.S. Golf Industry Launches #inviteHER Campaign

Topgolf to begin construction in Henrico; land deal still pending

Arcis Golf Named to Inc. 5000 List of America's Fastest-Growing Private Companies 

Royal New Kent: Rediscovering the Maverick

Farmington CC's Formula for Ever-Forward Thinking

Club Prophet Systems announces participation in NGCOA's 2nd annual Golf Business TechCon

Aug Perspective: Developers 1, Golf Course Homeowners 0

Yamaha Golf Car Reveals the New UMAX Rally

CIB: Why The Union League Club of Chicago Is the "One"

Fall Golf Trip Planning Has Never Been Easier

July Golf Weather Impact: Flat in Golf's "Apex" Weather Month

New Agronomy Vendors to ICS Marketplace

World's Largest Golf Outing

EZLinks Golf Partners with KPGA

Is Your Website ADA Compliant?

July OtR abstract: Is Industry Course Correction Costing Us Golfers?

Are Country Clubs Fading Away?, New England Golf, HOA's and more!

H-2B Returning Worker Exemption Added to 2019 DHS Appropriations Bill

Independence GC Re-Opens

Topgolf at TechCon18

National Affordable Golf Program Grows By 120 Percent

Property Preview - BY APPOINTMENT!

Entegra Extends Procurement Services with Cost Savings to NGCOA Members

Golf Course Appraisal, Consulting & Brokerage - "We Wrote the Book"

Listen Now: Golf Business Podcast Episode 4

Teesnap Sees Impressive Growth in First Half of 2018

Meet Serious Contenders for the Best in Golf Course Tech

 

 

Chronogolf Raises $2 Million Round of Funding, Expands in US, Canada, and Europe Golf Management & POS Software Market

Jun Weather Impact: Winning Streak Stops at 1

Club Car Releasing New Customizable, Job-Specific Showcase Vehicles

 

 

Chronogolf

Appraisal Standards & Golf Courses, More Drones and Acquisition Opportunities

CIB: What Makes a Good Golf Club Great?

June Perspective: Which course types are highest closure candidates?

NGCOA Podcast featuring Elisa Gaudet, Del Ratcliffe, Rock Lucas and Mark Loustalot

Teesnap Adds Four New Account Managers As Company Continues to Expand

Club Managers Association of America Changes Name to Club Management Association of America

Three Decades Later, Strange's U.S. Open Double Still Resonates

Women & Girls Golf Is Showcased Around The World

Increase revenue with dynamic pricing - Priswing

May Weather Impact: We finally catch a break!

ClubCorp Finds New CEO, Pillsbury

May OtR XS: Yield Management or Dynamic Pricing: Which is right for you?

Group Leader Free, Cooler Summer Trips and A Revolution

Shuttered local golf course finds a buyer

European General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)

Save on GOLFZON'S Top-Rated, Award-Winning Simulators

Zoning, Drones and the Private Club Mission

VSGA names Smiley new Executive Director

Save Your Seat for NCA's "Employee Classification" Webinar

Golf Course Acquisition Opportunity just 12 miles from Washington Monument (MD)

New Executive Director Selected

The Water's Edge Invitation

 

 

May Perspective: NGF says "Golfer base growing again!"

Kiskiack Golf Club Goes Solar

The National Golf Foundation Issues 2018 Golf Industry Report

Simulator-powered golf venue planned near Scott's Addition

Golden Horseshoe Golf Club Releases Golf Event Schedule

National Golf Club at Tantallon in Ft. Washington, MD Offered

Apr OtR XS:'17 Golf Consumer Base Shows Decelerating Decline

A Big Step Forward, A Big Step Backwards, Tax Assessment Valuation & More

R4R Auction Now Open - Tell Your Members

WE ARE GOLF Reports 22% Increase in U.S. Golf Economic Impact Ahead of National Golf Day

Club Prophet Systems: Signs On As Bronze Partner

WE ARE GOLF, Topgolf Extend Partnership for National Golf Day

Apr Perspective: Tough weather Q1 but some encouraging technology news

Golf The Beach and the Mountains in Virginia

Golf Property Taxes, Your Management Company, HOA's and More

Newly Discovered Historical Evidence Leads To Bunker Renovation At Cavalier Golf And Yacht Club

CaddieNow Hires Shannon Kneisler As Marketing Manager

Women’s Golf Day Poised For Record Growth In 2018

McNamara Named MAPGA Golf Professional Of The Year

Rain Bird Becomes NGCOA's Newest Corporate Partner

Local Golf Course Sells for $2M

GGA Insights: Millenial Research, Performance Intelligence, George Pinches

Important Update Regarding Council Leadership

Simulation gives golf a real edge for growth

So long, Hanover Country Club.  Hello, Hanover Golf Club

NGCOA Smart Buy Partner Steele Benefits Announces New NGCOA Member Benefit

Some golf leaders drop ball on tax reform

GIS, Are All Golf Courses Alike? Bunkers & More

Atlantic Dunes is NGCOA Course of the Year

Local golf club under contract; two sister courses closed for now

February Perspective: Will Virtual Golf Eclipse Reality?

Cypress Creek Golfers' Club Buyer's Preview

2018 NGCOA Smart Buy Guide - Click Here

Jan Golf Weather Impact: No Favors from Mother Nature

GolfNow Books The Martin Agency For Consumer Brand Engagement

On Par: UVa's new home at Birdwood is making progress

Virginia Golf Vacations Update

Register now - Mid-Atlantic Regional Conference - #1 event of the year

Landscapes mgmt. portfolio tops 50 properties

Palmer, Hiers Headline 2018 USGA Service Award Winners

PGA TOUR Commissioner Jay Monahan Named WGF Chairman for 2018

Sexual Harrassment Awareness -- NEW session just added!



Join Our Email List